Service Center

At Kelly Insurance, we want you to know that we are always willing to assist you.  We represent many carriers, most of which are listed below. If you wish to contact your carrier directly for claims or bill payments, we are providing the information on this page.

Personal Insurance: Homeowners & Auto

Erie Insurance Logo

Claims Phone: Call Kelly Insurance
Billing Phone: 800-458-0811
Pay Online: Click Here

foremost-logo

Claims Phone: 800-527-3907
Billing Phone: 888-888-0080
Pay Online: Click Here

progresive

Claims Phone: 877-776-2436
Billing Phone: 800-776-4737
Pay Online: Click Here

travellers

Claims Phone: 800-252-4633
Billing Phone: 800-842-5075
Pay Online: Click Here

hagerty insurance

Claims Phone: 800-385-0274
Service Phone: 877-922-9701
Pay Online: Click Here

Commercial Insurance

Erie Insurance Logo

Claims Phone: Call Kelly Insurance
Billing Phone: 800-458-0811
Pay Online: Click Here

EasternAlliance-Logo

Claims Phone: 717-396-7095
Billing Phone: 855-533-3444
Pay Online: Click Here

liberty-logo

Claims Phone: 877-783-3410
Billing Phone:888-398-8924
Pay Online: Click Here

progresive

Claims Phone: 877-776-2436
Billing Phone: 800-776-4737
Pay Online: Click Here

AIC Insurance

Claims Phone:  800-841-5241
Billing Phone: 800-492-5629
Pay online: Click Here

Pie Insurance

Claims Phone: 844-581-0828
Pay online: Click Here

Markel Insurance

Claims Phone: Coming Soon.
Billing Phone: 800-362-7537

Life Insurance

aetna-logo

Claims Phone: 800-872-3862
Billing Phone: 800-872-3862
Pay Online: Click Here

Independence-Blue-Cross-logo

Claims Phone: 800-275-2583
Billing Phone: 800-275-2583
Pay Online: Click Here

nationwide-logo

Claims Phone: 800-421-3535
Billing Phone: 800-543-3747
Pay Online: Click Here

united-healthcare-logo

Claims Phone: 877-844-4999
Billing Phone: 866-414-1959
Pay Online: Click Here

Guardian-Life-Insurance

Claims 800-627-4200
Billing 800-627-4200
Pay Online: Click Here

Principal life insurance

Claims 800-843-1371
Billing 800-843-1371
Pay Online Click Here


If your insurance carrier is not listed, please contact our office directly, and we will help you with your claim.
After-hours calls talk to our Answering Service.  Depending on the situation, an email message if sent to the appropriate person or office.  Non-emergencies will not get called back until business hours next work day.   Emergencies will be contacted promptly.     All phone numbers are sent to the Answering Service, not just our main number 610-489-9442.